Baseball: White America’s Pastime

I could be wrong (though not likely), but the results of an AP-AOL Sports poll released Thursday regarding the popularity of baseball – or, more correctly, the lack of popularity – were not all that surprising. Only about one in three Americans considers themselves a fan of the sport. That’s fewer than a similar poll revealed 16 years ago, but no surprise for myriad reasons, including the ongoing steroid mess.

Yes the stadiums have been rocking during the playoffs and ratings have been respectable, but as I watched the games I could not help but notice something more telling – the dearth of faces of color in the stands.

Photo

Yes, this is DE-troit.

Their absence was most telling on televised games from New York and Detroit, two of the nation’s most ethnically diverse cities. St. Louis also has a significant black population. But you wouldn’t know it from watching games at Busch Stadium. Sure, there were African American, Latino and Asian fans at the games. There had to be.

Baseball recognizes its lack of black players – only four will play in the upcoming World Series, all outfielders: Curtis Granderson, Craig Monroe and Marcus Thames of the Tigers, and the Cardinals’ Preston Wilson. (Wow, that’s only four more than played in last season’s Stanley Cup Finals) The sport is trying to address the troubling trend in a number of ways, including the creation on an academy in the heart of the ‘hood in Los Angeles, which baseball hopes will help teams find more talent from the area’s poorest areas.

But the elephant in the room everyone seems to be ignoring is the dearth of blacks and other people of color in the stands.

Is baseball now White America’s pastime?

The image “https://i1.wp.com/cache.boston.com/bonzai-fba/Globe_Photo/2004/10/28/1098953030_9399.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.

...in Boston Last Season…

This is not a new question, or a lame attempt at race-baiting. Four years ago, the Chicago Tribune asked the question and cited some telling stats. A poll conducted for the Chicago White Sox in 2000 found only 20 percent of the team’s fans where black. Sixty-three percent were white, 13 percent Latino (a figure that’s likely risen since due to the team’s success under Latino manager Ozzie Guillen). The article also cited a study by the Simmons Market Research Bureau in New York that found only 6.4 percent of fans attending Major League Baseball games were African American, down from 7.3 percent four years earlier.

For playoffs crowds, I’m not even sure pollsters could come up with black faces to even register statistically.

The image “https://i2.wp.com/us.news2.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/p/ap/20061015/capt.53483ae3a9d44bf08eda875403c07415.nlcs_mets_cardinals_baseball_sts221.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.

…and in St. Louis. (all photos courtesy AP.)

Here’s where the AP-AOL Sports poll missed the mark. The Tribune article also noted an ESPN/Chilton study revealing that only about 10 percent of people who considered themselves baseball fans were black. Nearly three in four were white, while 11.5 percent were Latino.

The AP-AOL poll could have been truly revealing if it had asked the race of those questioned and offered a breakdown of both those who said they were fans and those who said they weren’t.

Again the results probably wouldn’t be surprising. Baseball was the most popular sport among blacks of my parents generation. I was raised rooting for the St. Louis Cardinals and played the sport through high school. I doubt my son will make it that far. Since he began playing when he was eight years old, he’s always been either the only black player on the team, or one of only two or three. He’s 12 now and played this summer. He watches the games with me, but only in short bursts – usually to pick up hitting tips. And while he claims the Yankees as his team, he cared not one iota when they were swept from the playoffs by the Tigers. (That it happened while he was asleep is another story altogether.)

His closet is packed with basketball and football jerseys, but not a single baseball shirt.

There is no easy solution. Baseball does not have a transcended black star who resonates with young blacks (Sorry Derek Jeter). The last “cool” black baseball player may have been Ken Griffey, Jr., who’s now well past his prime.

Baseball is right to focus energy and resources to attract and nurture the next generation of black players. But the fruits of those efforts will not manifest themselves for years. More must be done now to cultivate this generation of black fans, and to get more ethnic diversity into the stadiums across the nation. Otherwise the image of the sport at its most visible time will continue to fade to white.

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “Baseball: White America’s Pastime

  1. Barry Adams says:

    I went to the Mets playoff games and saw other faces that looked like mine,but not many. However I saw more than I do at work. Economics is the barrier not the sport. If you discount ex ball players, how many paying customers go to the Knicks game? I KNOW I have never spent $500 to take my family of four.

    I read your blog every day. I enjoyed seeing Ali’s picture as he always reminds me of what is possible,not impossible.

    Miami football is a fraternity. Graduates continue in the fraternity tradition. I have witnessed this behavior in my own fraternity, Kappa Alpha Psi. At times frats can lose themselves to their identities.

    Roy, do you really expect Miami to punish themselves to the tune of $5 million? That is the fee for a mid level bowl game. I hope Miami can make a national championship comeback next year unless they are playing USC.

    Barry

  2. Bill says:

    Roy,

    I’ve re-energized my passion as a long-time Mets fan
    (I never forgave Frank Cashen for declaring that Darryl
    Strawberry wasn’t a $5 million a year ballplayer in 1990…)
    enough to watch a good portion of their series vs. St. Louis…

    …and as usual, I was struck by the “Whiteness” of the stadium
    crowds…

    But I do have a question about the ongoing “no Blacks in the Majors”
    discussion: how come when I was a kid, Roberto Clemente, Orlando Cepeda, Rico Carty, Manny Mota, Minnie Minoso,etc…were all considered “Black”?

    When I was ten I had a Budweiser guide of former and current top, Black
    baseballers — it included everybody from Satchel Paige to Manny Sanguillen…

    …but today, Carlos Delgado, Jose Reyes, and David Ortiz, etc…are
    “Hispanic/Latino”?

    To the extent that we believe that folks of African descent are racially
    considered “Black” (no matter what that percentage of “African” may be, according to White racism’s “one-drop rule”…), how did the Spanish-speakers get voted off the island?

    If David Ortiz and “los hermanos” are “Black,” then aren’t we talking more about ethnic/nationality issues and changing cultural preferences (i.e. southern-heritage, African Americans are eschewing baseball…),rather than issues of traditional racial exclusion?

    If Derek Jeter is “Black” but David Ortiz isn’t (Ortiz is what my late father would have labeled back in the day: “Black as the ace of spades”…), then maybe we should be questioning what “Black” means in 2006…

    P.S. If the response is that we know we’re Black when the White man let’s us know we are, then “Blackness” itself has become quite flimsy…

  3. Daryl says:

    Roy:

    African Americans did not leave the wonderful sport of baseball. Baseball left African Americans. Major league baseball still upholds the spirit of Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis. Judge Landis was a staunch segregationist who insisted on keeping major league baseball America’s past time by keeping it white. Bill Veeck stated that Judge Landis prevented him from purchasing the Philadelphia Phillies after he learned of Mr. Veeck’s plans to intergrate the team.

    Baseball stopped marketing the wonderful game of baseball to the African American community after Henry Aaron broke Babe Ruth’s home run record. Let us not forget the slanderous words of the former owner of the the “Big Red Machine”. I won’t even mention her name or statements, but I do firmly believe that she expressed openly the sentiments of the other owners. Let someone else speak her name and her notorious comments about African American baseball players. I am still angry about those awful comments.

    African Americans still love America’s past time, but baseball does not love African Americans. Believe what you see!

  4. karen says:

    Actually many young black kids do look up to Derek Jeter. He is usually the only baseball player that they know, other than Barry Bonds. Jeter is a favorite amongst many African American children

  5. Dan says:

    Why do people make latinos a different race? The majority of latinos are white. I wish they stop putting them in a separate category. Actually I think it is more unting than dividing.

  6. Dan says:

    Why do people make latinos a different race? The majority of latinos are white. I wish they stop putting them in a separate category. Actually I think it is more unting than dividing. My mother is latino but says she is white. She doesn’t understand why people separate most latinos who are white in a different category. She feel Spanish more and it is as European as any Italians Greeks and Irish.

  7. Bob Kavanagh says:

    A photo of Boston fans is shown above with the caption

    …in Boston Last Season…

    Sorry to say that this is a picture of St. Louis

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: